Obama’s Handling Of The Gulf Disaster: The Psychology Behind The Criticisms
Criticism of Pres. Obama’s leadership during the Gulf of Mexico disaster has been mounting in recent weeks. People are worried and concerned about the huge, unrelenting flow of oil and what it may do to our entire ecology. The President’s press conference mitigated some of those criticisms, but many view his response as too little, too late. They ask why didn’t he take command and speak to the nation several weeks ago?
A great deal of the criticism is justified, and it’s coming from both right and left. It includes not only his personal leadership but more broadly, the role and response of the federal government.
But I think there’s another, additional basis for the criticism: The psychology of people’s fears when they’re confronted with such disasters, and how that shapes what they look for in a leader.
That is, the psychology of the criticism directed at Obama reflects something deeper than questions about BP’s performance and/or untrustworthiness, given the cozy relationship big oil has had with the federal government. It’s also deeper than debate over what government’s proper role should be in dealing with this or other man-made disasters.
To explain, let’s take a look at some criticisms coming from both the left and the right: On May 17, MSNBC’s Chris Matthews erupted in anger at the oil disaster. He railed about the profits BP reaps as it fails to fix it, but also criticized the Obama administration for letting BP control the disaster response. Calling this “disaster capitalism,” (from Naomi Klein’s The Shock Doctrine) he questioned why the President doesn’t just “nationalize that industry and get the job done,” adding that in China, “they execute people for this.”
That’s typical of Matthews’ sometimes over-the-top passion, but he’s been making solid criticism of the President for, in essence, looking like an observer, standing on the sidelines, instead of getting in there and doing something.
Similarly, other critics have openly wondered why Obama hasn’t shown more passion, like pounding the table, showing outrage; perhaps shouting.
Some conservative critics have Read more…
Climate Change & Green Business, Psychological health in a post-globalized world





